Best Top Rated Maui Hawaii Restaurants

denise6358
Nov 2
4 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

Here are five of the best‑rated restaurants on the island of Maui, Hawai‘i — each offering a distinct flavor of local cuisine, ambience, and island hospitality. I’ve included what makes them special, what to try, and some helpful tips.

1. Mama’s Fish House — Paia (North Shore)

4.8•Seafood restaurant

A legendary institution on Maui: Mama’s Fish House is located in Paia on the North Shore and is consistently ranked among the island’s top fine‑dining spots. Em's On The Road+3Tripadvisor+3Pride of Maui+3

Why it stands out

The seafood is sourced daily from local fishermen, with a rotating menu based on what’s fresh. Pride of Maui+1
It has an unforgettable setting — oceanfront, lush tropical surroundings, a true Maui dining experience.
It has earned acclaim: for example, the restauran was a semi‑finalist in the James Beard Foundation awards. mamasfishhouse.com

What to try
The “Stuffed Mahi Mahi” featured in some guides. Pride of Maui
A classic dessert like the “Chocolate Pearl” — many note it as a must. Em's On The Road

Tips
Reservations are highly recommended well in advance, especially for dinner.
Dress up a bit — it leans more formal than casual beach‑fare.
Arrive early for golden‑hour views.

2. Merriman’s Kapalua — Kapalua / West Maui

4.7•Restaurant

Located in Kapalua on the west side of Maui, Merriman’s is recognized for its “Hawai‘i Regional Cuisine” approach — fresh local fish and produce executed with care.

Why it’s a favorite

Strong reviews cite it as a “Maui tradition” for fine dining. Tripadvisor+1
High ratings: Google/Yelp show 4.7 stars among many reviews.

What to try
Fresh catch of the day — mahi mahi, ono, or whatever local fish is featured.
Pair with island vegetables or produce‑centric sides.

Tips
Great for a special dinner in West Maui; the location is convenient if staying in Lahaina/Kapalua.
Sunset reservations are ideal for both food and view.

3. Mala Ocean Tavern — Lahaina (Oceanfront)

An oceanfront gem along Front Street in Lahaina, Mala Ocean Tavern offers a more relaxed but still top‑tier dining option.

Why it’s worth visiting

Recognized with awards for oceanfront dining (“Gold for Best Oceanfront Dining” in Maui’s ʻAipono Awards) as of 2025. Mala Tavern
Fresh fish, Hawaiian‑style cuisine, a relaxed yet elevated vibe.

What to try
Freshly caught local fish prepared simply.
A sunset cocktail on the patio overlooking the ocean.

Tips
Because of its location in Lahaina, consider visiting early and then enjoying a stroll on Front Street after dinner.
Parking can fill up — aim to arrive a bit ahead of your reservation.

4. Nalu’s South Shore Grill — Kihei (South Maui)

For a more relaxed beach‑casual spot on the south side of the island (Kihei), Nalu’s stands out.

Why foodies love it

Strong user reviews: 4.7 stars across over 4,600 reviews.
Featured in “10 Best Restaurants in Maui” list on TripAdvisor. Tripadvisor
Known for excellent starters (e.g., calamari) and casual beach‑vibe fare.

What to try
The calamari and crab‑cakes that reviewers often mention. Tripadvisor+1
Perhaps a local beer and a fish taco for a more laid‑back meal.

Tips
Because it’s more casual, it’s ideal for lunch or dinner without the formality of the fine dining spots.
Can get busy around sunset; if you’re flexible, go earlier.

5. Paia Fish Market — Paia (North Shore)

A beloved local gem for fresh fish and casual dining in Paia, perfect for a lunch stop or relaxed dinner.

Why it makes the list

Frequently cited in “must‑eat” lists for Maui. She Saves She Travels+1
Solid reviews: 4.6 stars from 5,000+ reviews.

What to try
Mahi Mahi plate or fish tacos — reviewers rave about the freshness and flavor. She Saves She Travels
Pair it with a local side salad or tropical drink.

Tips
Because it’s on the North Shore, plan it either before or after a scenic drive (e.g., the famous Road to Hana) or beach visit.
More casual atmosphere — no formal dress required.

Final Thoughts & Planning Notes

Reservations: For the fine‑dining spots (e.g., Mama’s Fish House, Merriman’s) booking ahead is strongly recommended — they fill up, especially during high season.
Dress Code & Atmosphere: Maui dining ranges from resort‑formal to beach casual. Check with each restaurant.
Timing & View: Many of these restaurants have ocean views or special sunset vistas — if you care about the view, aim for early evening slots.
Local Ingredients & Sustainability: A common thread is the emphasis on locally caught fish, island produce, and Hawai‘i Regional Cuisine — meaning you’re getting something that’s both fresh and rooted in place.
Budget: Some of these are premium dining experiences — plan accordingly if you want the full experience (prime table/view + multi‑course meal).
Explore All Regions: Maui has distinct dining areas—North Shore (Paia), West Maui (Lahaina/Kapalua), South Maui (Kihei/Wailea). If your stay allows, try to mix across regions.